Skip to content

Opening book details…

Can I read Before Prozac : the troubled history of mood disorders in psychiatry on EtoBox?

Before Prozac : the troubled history of mood disorders in psychiatry by Shorter, Edward is a health book available to read on EtoBox.

What is Before Prozac : the troubled history of mood disorders in psychiatry about?

Shorter's critique is complicated and multifactorial (and he frequently gets distracted by historical curiosities), but lives may depend on it. The main thrust of his argument is that Psychiatry has not progressed as other medical specialties have, because the classification of illnesses and the medications used to treat them are inferior to the state of the art 40 years ago. This came about because 1. Major Depression was so broadly defined as to be a meaningless diagnosis, 2. The FDA decreed that drugs had to be indicated specifically for a particular use (antidepressant, antipsychotic, anxiolytic) 3. The early FDA arbitrarily wiped out or vilified whole classes of drugs as an exercise of power, and 4. the later FDA adopted a standard for efficacy of double-blind trials against placebo, without regard for relative effectiveness of other drugs. The political document known as the DSM is certainly an easy target. Shorter's main objection is the classification of depressive disorders. He believes that clinically useful categories would be melacholic depression (what used to be called clinical depression, meaning slowed physical reactions, inability to get out of bed, high cortiso

Who reads Before Prozac : the troubled history of mood disorders in psychiatry?

It is typically read by readers building habits, skills, productivity or wellbeing.

Common subject areas: self-improvement, productivity, wellness.

Author
Shorter, Edward
Publisher
IRL Press at Oxford University Press
Published
2009
Language
EN
ISBN
9780195368741
Category
health
Subjects
History, Medical, Science
Rating
4.1 / 5 (9 ratings)
Updated
2026-03-14

More by Shorter, Edward

Browse all works by Shorter, Edward